Cream together butter and sugar.
Beat in egg.
Add vanilla, salt, and flour. Mix until just incorporated for soft cookies, mix well for dough that doesn't spread.
Wrap air-tight in cling wrap. Refrigerate until firm, about 1 hour.
Roll to 1/4 inch thick, cut shapes, and freeze until stiff and completely unbendable. Like you could stand it up on an edge and there'd be zero flop, and it you tried too hard to bend it the cookie would snap. It takes a couple hours to freeze thoroughly.
Bake at 325 degrees F for 33 minutes, until edges are very slightly golden.
When baking large orders, make dough in 2x batches in the stand mixer.
Wrap, chill, mix dough by hand, then roll onto a half sheet tray, wrap again, and chill. Cut directly from tray.
For the large cookies I make, I estimate 7 cookies per 1x batch.
If baking 3 trays at one: bake for 39 minutes total, rotating trays by rack and posistion twice. 3-4 of my large cookies can fit on a tray, so budget 1 hour per dozen cookies.
Save this recipe to your collection
Sign up free
Discussion